I am sick of the extraordinary amount of bullshit we have invented to avoid confronting the simple fact that we are physical organisms. We spend our lives discussing consciousness, morality, psychological fulfillment, spirituality, beauty, and the supposedly higher dimensions of human existence, while treating the very body responsible for producing these experiences as some unfortunate biological inconvenience. We are told that appearance does not matter, that physical strength is superficial, that beauty is subjective to the point of meaninglessness, and that the mind somehow occupies a privileged position above the animal in which it resides. Yet practically everything we know about human physiology contradicts this comfortable little fiction. Your thoughts emerge from a brain. Your brain is an organ. Your personality, emotions, desires, memories, and intellectual capacities depend upon the continuous operation of a biological system that can be strengthened, neglected, injured, poisoned, exhausted, and eventually destroyed. There is no ghost piloting this machine. There is no consciousness conveniently exempt from the conditions of physical reality. You are the machine, and it is the most extraordinary thing you will ever possess.
Nietzsche understood this. In Thus Spoke Zarathustra, he rejects the separation of the supposedly noble mind from the inferior flesh, recognizing the body as an intelligence whose complexity precedes conscious reasoning. Yukio Mishima, particularly in Sun and Steel, approached the same problem through his obsessive confrontation with physical beauty, bodybuilding, sunlight, and the limitations of language. Mishima had spent much of his early life immersed in literature, constructing elaborate worlds through words while remaining dissatisfied with his own physical existence.
Eventually, he discovered something that no amount of literary sophistication could provide: the resistance of steel, the sensation of muscular exertion, the development of physical form, and the extraordinary reality of a body that could no longer be reduced to an intellectual abstraction. He described his pursuit of physical beauty as an attempt to restore something that ought to have existed in the first place, writing that steel returned the body toward its natural form. The body was no longer an embarrassing attachment to his imagination. It had become an artistic undertaking in its own right.
And I think this is where Mishima understood something that modern consumer civilization has almost completely lost. Beauty is not merely a collection of arbitrary preferences manufactured by advertisers, nor is it exclusively an intellectual judgment that we consciously construct through reasoning. There are forms of beauty that seem to announce themselves before we possess the vocabulary necessary to describe them. The movement of an animal, the symmetry of a healthy organism, the expression of genuine affection, the proportions of a classical sculpture, the sight of sunlight passing through trees after a storm. We recognize something in these experiences that language can approach but never completely possess.
Mishima's own formulation in Sun and Steel is particularly revealing: "For me, beauty is always retreating from one's grasp." There is something almost agonizing about the observation. We encounter beauty, attempt to explain it, classify it, reproduce it, and preserve it, yet the experience itself remains irreducible to our explanations. Beauty can be studied through biology, perception, culture, and aesthetics, but the description is not the experience. The mathematical analysis of a melody is not the melody. The explanation of sunlight is not the sensation of standing beneath it.
And we know when something has been falsified. Not infallibly, of course, and not according to some universal aesthetic measurement that every human being possesses identically. But we frequently recognize the difference between something cultivated with care and something manufactured to imitate the appearance of cultivation.
A garden and a plastic imitation of a garden. An actual friendship and a commercially simulated relationship. A physically capable human being and the purchased costume of one. A beautiful object constructed to endure and some disposable piece of garbage designed to survive precisely long enough to be sold. Modern capitalism has become extraordinarily proficient at reproducing the external symbols of beautiful things while removing the qualities that made them desirable in the first place. We buy artificial experiences, artificial status, artificial identities, and artificial substitutes for practically every ordinary pleasure of being alive. Everything must be packaged, monetized, optimized, advertised, and eventually discarded. Even the rebellion against consumerism arrives in the form of another product.
And nowhere is this more disgusting than the modern food industry.
Walk through a supermarket and actually examine what is being sold to you. Entire aisles devoted to sweetened cereals, industrially manufactured snacks, confectionery, refined starches, sugary beverages, and combinations of salt, sugar, fat, and texture developed to encourage repeated consumption. Of course, not every processed food is harmful, and the presence of an unfamiliar chemical name does not establish that something is poisonous. But the broader commercial arrangement is fucking revolting. Corporations spend extraordinary resources understanding consumer behavior, product placement, palatability, brand recognition, and the mechanisms through which people become habitual customers. Their profits depend upon selling products, not upon the long-term metabolic health of the populations purchasing them. We have constructed an environment in which nutritionally poor foods are inexpensive, convenient, heavily advertised, and available practically everywhere, and then pretend that the resulting patterns of overconsumption are exclusively failures of individual discipline.
Moderation, they tell us. Everything in moderation.
What an extraordinarily convenient philosophy for an industry whose profits depend upon people returning to purchase more.
And the consumer is expected to exercise perfect restraint while surrounded by products whose commercial success depends upon encouraging the opposite. Read the nutritional information, they say. Examine the ingredients. Compare the labels. Educate yourself. Certainly, people should understand what they consume, but why should purchasing ordinary food require navigating a marketplace filled with products whose packaging and advertising routinely communicate impressions of health that their nutritional composition may not justify? Why should an exhausted parent returning from work be expected to conduct a miniature investigation into food chemistry every time he purchases dinner? Why have we accepted an environment where the burden of avoiding unnecessary harm falls almost entirely upon the individual, while the companies profiting from the environment celebrate their commitment to consumer choice?
The same absurdity extends into our homes. We heat food in unsuitable plastic containers, tolerate unnecessary combustion fumes, purchase disposable materials whose degradation creates environmental problems, and expose ourselves to avoidable pollutants because the consequences are frequently invisible or delayed. Burning plastic can release hazardous substances, and certain cookware and food-contact materials require sensible precautions. This does not mean that every plastic object is dangerous or every nonstick pan is poisoning its owner. It means that the material circumstances of our existence deserve considerably more attention than they receive. We have somehow become more interested in the technological sophistication of our household appliances than in the quality of the air we breathe, the food we consume, and the environments in which our bodies must continuously function. And look at what has happened to physical competence. Obesity, inactivity, poor cardiovascular health, and preventable metabolic disease have become enormous public-health problems. We cannot reliably establish how many Americans are capable of running five kilometers continuously, but the broader prevalence of inadequate physical fitness is hardly mysterious. We have normalized sedentary living to such an extraordinary extent that somebody who runs regularly, lifts weights, swims, climbs, and maintains a healthy body composition is frequently considered unusually dedicated to fitness rather than ordinarily capable of using his own organism. School physical education remains inconsistent, and genuine physical development is too often treated as something separate from intellectual education. A child may spend years preparing for examinations without ever developing meaningful strength, endurance, or practical knowledge of how to maintain his physical health.
How can this possibly be considered an adequate preparation for life?
Mishima's obsession with bodybuilding becomes much more comprehensible when understood against this background. He was not merely attempting to become attractive. He was trying to give his existence a physical form, to reconcile the beauty he encountered in art with the reality of his own flesh. I do not share his romanticization of violent death, nor do I think muscularity guarantees courage or moral excellence. But the underlying ambition remains magnificent: to cultivate the body as deliberately as one cultivates intelligence, artistic judgment, or character. Physical training is an encounter with an external reality that refuses to be persuaded by rhetoric. You cannot negotiate with gravity. You cannot purchase cardiovascular endurance through an advertisement. You cannot develop genuine strength by constructing an elaborate intellectual theory of what strength ought to mean. The organism must actually perform the work. It must confront resistance, adapt, recover, and return. And in doing so, something remarkable happens: an abstract intention becomes a material achievement.
This is why I am increasingly skeptical of any psychological or spiritual philosophy that systematically neglects the body. The brain is not an arbitrary metaphysical object floating somewhere outside the nervous system. It is a biological organ whose operation depends upon sleep, nutrition, circulation, metabolic health, and countless physiological processes. Psychotherapy and psychiatric treatment can be extraordinarily valuable, and serious mental illnesses cannot simply be cured through exercise. But why do we so frequently approach psychological suffering through endless reflection while neglecting the physical conditions under which consciousness operates? Why should an exhausted, sedentary, nutritionally neglected individual spend years analyzing his dissatisfaction without also addressing the bodily circumstances contributing to it? The clergy may speak of spiritual emptiness, the psychologist of maladaptive thinking, and the philosopher of existential alienation, but the organism remains an organism. Sometimes the human being requires intellectual understanding. Sometimes he requires medical treatment. And sometimes he requires sleep, nutritious food, sunlight, meaningful physical activity, and a life that involves something beyond sitting motionless beneath artificial lighting.
Run. Lift. Swim. Eat properly. Sleep. Spend time outdoors. Maintain the body through which every other experience becomes possible. No, drinking a gallon of spring water and running five miles every morning will not miraculously cure every illness, and prescribing such a routine indiscriminately would be ridiculous. But the underlying necessity of physical cultivation is not some fashionable wellness invention. It is a biological reality, and no amount of philosophical sophistication can exempt us from it.
Yet I do not think the highest purpose of physical excellence is merely to become attractive, sexually desirable, professionally successful, or even exceptionally healthy. These are legitimate benefits, but they are not the entirety of what I am attempting to describe. What interests me most is the possibility of constructing an existence that possesses something resembling the beauty of a well-composed work of art. A life in which intellectual curiosity, physical competence, love, responsibility, courage, and appreciation of the world are not separate activities competing for attention, but parts of the same human undertaking. We should be constructing poetry out of our lives, not merely writing poetry about the lives we wish we possessed. And poetry, in this sense, does not mean theatrical behavior or some ridiculous attempt to transform every ordinary activity into a performance. It means cultivating a life whose actions possess coherence, substance, and a beauty that does not depend upon constant recognition.
There is something extraordinarily beautiful about a human being who confronts the cruelty of physical existence without becoming cruel himself.
Consider the actual conditions under which we live. We inhabit a universe that does not appear organized around our happiness, whose physical laws do not suspend themselves when we are frightened, exhausted, innocent, or deserving of some better outcome. Disease does not evaluate moral character. Gravity does not forgive carelessness. The passage of time gradually destroys everything we construct, including the bodies through which we experience the world. We are temporary organisms existing upon a small planet, surrounded by physical processes whose scale and indifference exceed practically everything our imaginations can comprehend. And yet, in the midst of this arrangement, a human being can stand upright, breathe deeply, observe the world, and decide to participate in it without demanding that existence become fair before he begins.
I find that beautiful. More beautiful, in many respects, than the dramatic glorification of suffering that occasionally appears in the writings of Mishima and Nietzsche. The calm human spirit confronting an uncaring universe possesses a kind of dignity that does not require theatrical self-destruction. A man who knows that he will die, that his strength will eventually disappear, that the people he loves are vulnerable, and that his achievements possess no guarantee of permanence, yet continues to build, protect, discover, and love anyway, has achieved something that no consumer product can possibly reproduce. He does not need to pretend that suffering is desirable. He does not need to worship death. He does not need to invent some magnificent metaphysical explanation establishing that the universe secretly admires his courage. He simply understands the conditions of his existence and continues living with as much competence, affection, intelligence, and composure as he can cultivate.
This, I think, is where physicalism becomes unexpectedly beautiful.
If consciousness is produced through the organization of physical matter, then the human capacity for love, courage, artistic creation, and intellectual discovery is not diminished by its biological origins. Quite the opposite. Matter has become capable of appreciating matter. An organism produced through evolution can understand the stars, recognize the beauty of a forest, experience affection for another organism, and deliberately cultivate capacities that did not exist at its birth. We do not require a supernatural explanation for the beauty of this condition. Nor does a physicalist interpretation require contempt for religious thought, whose traditions sometimes contain extraordinary insights into suffering, love, sacrifice, and the responsibilities of embodied existence. Deterministic physicalist monism remains a philosophical position rather than an uncontested scientific demonstration of every aspect of reality, but its practical implications are sufficiently serious: our lives unfold within one physical order, and whatever meaning we construct must eventually be expressed through actions occurring inside that order.
And action is precisely what modern consumer civilization has become so extraordinarily effective at replacing.
Instead of physical competence, it sells equipment. Instead of beauty, it sells cosmetic imitation. Instead of nutrition, it sells products claiming to provide health. Instead of community, it sells platforms. Instead of adventure, it sells entertainment. Instead of genuine intellectual development, it sells the appearance of sophistication. And instead of helping people become capable of participating directly in the world, it increasingly encourages them to experience existence through representations manufactured by somebody else. The consumer purchases the clothes of the adventurer without visiting the wilderness, the books of the philosopher without applying their arguments, the supplements of the athlete without training, and the instruments of the craftsman without learning to construct anything. He acquires the symbols of capacities he has never developed. And the market, naturally, is delighted.
I have no interest in another expensive product promising to restore some allegedly lost conception of authentic human existence. I have no interest in purchasing a fashionable identity built around discipline, masculinity, spirituality, or rebellion. The point is not to acquire another collection of objects or to perform another personality for an audience. The point is to develop actual capacities. To become stronger, healthier, more capable of understanding reality, more willing to participate in the world, and less dependent upon commercial substitutes for ordinary human experiences.
Stop buying the appearance of a life you could actually live. Go into the physical world. Learn how to use your hands. Develop your cardiovascular endurance. Become strong enough to carry something useful. Learn to prepare food from recognizable ingredients. Maintain your home. Study science and philosophy, but allow the knowledge to deepen your participation in existence rather than replace it. Spend time with people you love without constantly converting their presence into photographs, messages, and digital records.
Experience sunlight, rain, exhaustion, hunger, affection, physical accomplishment, and the extraordinary peacefulness of an evening after a day in which you have actually done something. None of this requires an elaborate ideology. Most of it does not require particularly much money. And practically none of it can be purchased in its completed form.
The purpose of cultivating the body is not to create an immortal statue of oneself. That would be another form of vanity, and a particularly futile one considering the biological conditions under which we exist. The body will age. Strength will decline. Beauty will change. Eventually the organism will cease functioning altogether, regardless of how carefully it has been maintained. But impermanence does not invalidate cultivation. A garden is not worthless because winter will arrive. A beautiful piece of music is not meaningless because the final note eventually disappears. And a human life does not require permanence to possess dignity, coherence, or beauty. We cannot command the universe to care about us. We cannot negotiate with entropy, abolish every form of suffering, or guarantee that the things we create will survive us. But we can refuse to spend our brief interval of consciousness consuming artificial substitutes for experiences that remain available in the world itself. We can maintain our bodies, cultivate our intelligence, develop useful abilities, protect the people we love, and approach the inevitable difficulties of existence without surrendering either our composure or our appreciation of its beauty.
Perhaps that is the highest form of physicalism I can imagine. Not the worship of muscle, not the reduction of humanity to biological machinery, and certainly not the obsession with becoming physically superior to other people. It is the recognition that the body is the extraordinary material through which a human life becomes possible, and that the proper response to this fact is neither shame nor neglect, but cultivation.
The universe is indifferent. The body is temporary. The world is frequently cruel, and nothing guarantees that our efforts will succeed.
And yet a person can stand beneath the evening sky, exhausted from honest work, conscious of his own mortality, and remain extraordinarily glad to be alive.
I think there is very little in existence more beautiful than that.
No comments:
Post a Comment